Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Deprivation of Southern Punjab

Punjab is the largest populated province of Pakistan. With 56 percent of the total population of the country, it has enormous socio-economic inter-district differences causing inequality among the districts. This paper discusses the causes and impacts of these differences by shedding light on historical and chronological state of affairs. The colonial era and its socioeconomic impacts on Punjab, the population share of districts, and the association between inequality and growth in the province have been recognized in this paper as the fundamental factors responsible for enormous inter-district disparities in Punjab province. The Colonial rulers built Canal Colonies, Cantonments, and railway networks in the province. They also recruited large number of citizens of North and Central Punjab in the Army. These colonial efforts played the key role in rooting the inequalities between the Northern and Southern regions of Punjab.

Causes of inequality in Punjab

This part of the paper deals with the colonial efforts that brought inequality in Punjab. The three main causes of inequality have been mentioned below.

Canal Colonization

The British established nine canal colonies during the period from 1885 to 1947 14 . The canal colonies were named as 'crown waste'. The formation of canals was carried out for bringing water to the 'crown waste' 15 . The British colonial rulers encouraged migration from the nearby populous districts to these canal colonies by establishing residential areas in them. They 9 Mr. Cheema is Lecturer in Economics in Department of Economics at University of Sargodha, Pakistan.

10 Mr. Maqbool is a Foreign Faculty Professor in Department of Economics at University of Sargodha, Pakistan.

11 Mr. Gohar Zaman is the Chairman of Special Committee on Demarcation of Provinces.

12 Engerman and Schollof have discussed the development experience of the regions having the factor endowments. They discussed this in their sequential papers published in the years 1997, 2002, & 2006. 13 Ibid.

14 Khawaja, 2012 Javaid 6 also allotted residential plots 16 to the people and transformed the barren area into an agricultural market 17 . The irrigated land from the canals was only three million acres in the year 1885 which then increased to fourteen million acres in the next sixty years 18 . This caused prosperous to the regions of canal colonies. The deprivation starts from here as no canal colony was made in the South Punjab. Only the district of Multan had a single colony leaving behind all of the remaining Southern Punjab deserted.

On the other hand, the five districts of Central Punjab 19 had nine canal colonies in them and were benefitting from irrigating their lands. The path of inequality was established from here. The reason for constructing the canal colonies were apparent that five rivers used to pass through the Central Punjab. These regions had average rainfalls and the climate was appropriate for agriculture 20 . Meanwhile, the Southern Punjab regions had very low rainfall and less water resources 21 . This is necessary to mention that the British had their own pursuit of profits in their minds. They selected the most suitable land for irrigation because it would yield more production 15 Ibid.

16 Ibid. 17 Ali, 1988, p-3. 18 In 1947, the canal irrigated area in Punjab was 14 million acres. This is an increase of 366 percent in the region (Ali, 1988, p-3).

19 The Pakistani Central Punjab 20 Idrees argues this very well and mentions that the planned supply of water from the canals implied average rainfall in the area served by a canal ─ greater the rainfall lesser the water needed.

21 Average rainfall in Central Punjab Districts was 460 mm in the ten years 1921-1931While it was 158 mm in South Punjab regions. (Put together). Javaid 7 to the farmers. More production implied more tax-revenue generation for the British 22 . The canal colonies were the revenue generation tools for the British therefore, the British promoted them 23 .

The British also wanted to earn revenues for financing their own markets in Europe 24 . Therefore, they selected the most profitable lands in Punjab leaving behind the barren lands of Southern Punjab untouched.

Cantonments formed by the British

The British made Rawalpindi as military headquarter of the entire Indian Army 25 . There were eight cantonments in Punjab and five were in the three districts of Northern Punjab.

Cantonments were formed in order to provide suitable residence for the British-Indian Officers.

All of the necessary facilities were provided in the cantonments. The health, infrastructure and educational facilities were provided there. The schools 26 were made for the children of the officers. The market was set up near to the cantonments and sooner the markets turned into giant markets of buyers and sellers. The railway lines were set up for providing transportation facilities to the officers as well as for the transport of soldiers, arms and military items via train. The set up of railway lines entailed the involvement of large number of laborers and soon the railway emerged as the largest employee department of subcontinent. The formation of markets in the North Punjab regions and the set up of railway lines in Punjab gave much employment 22 Ali, 1988, p-3 23 Paustian, 1968, p.30 24 Islam, 1997 25 Khawaja, 2012 26 For example, The Lawrence School in Rawalpindi Javaid 8 opportunities to the inhabitants of North Punjab. Thus, the other than agriculture professions progressed and generated benefits for the North and Central Punjab regions 27 .

It is noticeable here that only one railway line passed through the South Punjab, thus the British neglected the South Punjab again 28 . Therefore, they remained uninformed by the employment opportunities in the railway. The inhabitants of South Punjab were neither invited nor encouraged to participate in the market of the North Punjab. The inhabitants of South Punjab did not have any significant agricultural product therefore they never travelled farther than their own land for trade purposes. The people of South Punjab prefer staying in their own land 29 . Thus, they remain deprived of the socio-economic progress taking place in the North and Central Punjab regions.

The British did not give attention to the region because they had no benefit for themselves in doing so. They did what they understood beneficial for themselves. Even, the construction of Railway lines was carried out in order to transport the raw materials gained from the subcontinent to their own land 30 . The British were extracting benefits from the subcontinent therefore; they let the deprivation of deprived regions continued. Thus, the South Punjab was continued to being ignored.

Military Recruitment in the Colonial era

As mentioned earlier that the British wanted more recruitments from the Central and Northern regions of Punjab because of the stronger physical fitness and warlike reputation of the 27 Khawaja, 2012 28 Ibid.

29 Darling, 1928, p.106. inhabitants of these regions. Most of the people from North and Central Punjab were Rajpoots and Sikhs who have great warlike reputation. The Rajppots have been very influential during the Mughals era. Rajpoots had associations with Mughals 31 and therefore they were always at the forefront for assisting the Mughals in fighting against the opposing parties. Concurrently, the Sikhs also had exceptional warlike reputations. The Rajpoots and Sikhs had greater population in Central, and Eastern Punjab 32 . Similarly, the Afghan origin people were living in the northwestern areas and also in North Punjab regions 33 . Therefore, the British wanted these people to be recruited in the Indian Army. For this, the British gave incentives to the inhabitants of these regions to join the army by offering them employment opportunities along with benefits.

The British gave lands and living allowances to the higher ranked soldiers and this urged the non-agricultural 34 inhabitants of North Punjab to join the Army. A large number of Central Punjab inhabitants also joined the army. This gave good employment opportunities to the unemployed residents of North and Central Punjab. The people of Punjab, after getting recruited into the British-Indian Army, also fought the first and second world wars for the British.

31 Rajpoots have been very influential in Punjab. The famous title of Raja was used by the Rajpoots. The emperor was called 'Maharaja'. The Rajpoots had their proud rule in Punjab and were never defeated in their entire rule. It was the Mughal Emperor Akbar (1556-1605) who married to the Princess Jodha, the Daughter of Maharaja Bharmal. Jodha was also named as Marium-uz-Zamani. This marriage relationship turned the affiliation of Rajpoots for Akbar and thus, the Rajpoots later served for the Mughal Empire. Akbar's famous advisor 'Raja Birbal' and many others have served the Mughals and have historical services in their names. (Smith, 1917;Abraham, 2000;Thomas, 2006) et.al.

Relationship between Inequality and Growth

The growth in Punjab during the colonial as well as in post colonial era caused increase in inequality. It has been found by the study conducted by Cheema and Sial that the growth in Punjab also increased inequality in the region. Their findings were: i) Poverty has positive relationship with inequality, ii) Difference arises between the gross and net elasticity of growth which is offset by inequality. Hence, they concluded with their study that the inequality has a significant positive relationship with growth in the country. They further found that the inequality in Punjab was the greatest because of the high growth in the Province. Their results 35 Khawaja, 2012 36 The British preferred granting from non-monetary benefits. They took the finances with them because the British had war loans upon them after the First World War (Leigh, 1922, p. 79-103) this was a tactic of granting 'their lands to themselves'. However, the British were successful enough to keep the grantees satisfied. Javaid 11 are affirmed by the fact that they have also found the growth elasticity of inequality higher in urban areas than in rural areas because the urban areas have more growth 38 .

This further establishes the fact that while the growth was going on in Punjab during the colonial rule, the inequality gap was increasing. Similarly, after the partition, the selected regions of Pakistani Punjab gained much focus from the Government of Pakistan for the continuation of developmental projects. The Growth of Punjab was increasing than other provinces concurrently;

it was increasing the inequality gap among the selected and non-selected districts 39 .

Population Share

The Government has the budget-sharing formula based on the population allocation of the regions. Therefore, the provincial budget allocations go in favor of the populous districts of the province. The districts in the center and north of Punjab have higher population than the South-West districts. Therefore, the North and Central districts get higher allocations of budgets and funds. On the other hand, the South-West regions of Punjab get small shares of the budget and allocated funds. Therefore, the population-share formula continues to deprive the South-West regions of Punjab 40 .

South Punjab: A current estimate of deprivation

In the current scenario, South Punjab lags behind other regions of Punjab in terms of available health facilities, employment opportunities, school enrolments, and growth. The South

Ahmed Cheema and Maqbool Sial, conducted 'A Pooled Regression Analysis' in 2012

39 The commercial and urban districts of Punjab like Lahore, Faisalabad, Rawalpindi, Sialkot, Sargodha, and Gujranwala gained much focus from the Govt. while the Southern Punjab regions were ignored for development projects. Here, the Southern Punjab regions have been referred as non-selected districts that are facing high deprivation and poverty.

Javaid 12

Punjab has minimal industrial set up. Moreover, the average landholdings of is also very small.

Although, the North Punjab inhabitants also have had small landholdings however, they got the alternate employment opportunities as mentioned in the previous section 41