Urban Regeneration as a Public Health Intervention
Published in Journal of Social Interventions: Theory and Practice 19 (3):38-51
5 views
Seen by:Globalization: the global marketplace and social determinants of health
Co-authored with Ronald Labonte; in Improving Equity in Health by
Addressing Social Determinants, edited by
The Commission on Social Determinants of Health Knowledge Networks,
Jennifer H Lee and Ritu Sadana (Geneva: WHO, 2012). This is the long-awaited compilation of findings from the knowledge networks that supported the work of the WHO Commission.
Multiple Forms of Perceived Discrimination and Health among Adolescents and Young Adults
Published in the Journal of Health and Social Behavior, June 2012: http://hsb.sagepub.com/content/early/2012/05/14/0022146512444289.abstr
Research on perceived discrimination has overwhelmingly focused on one form of discrimination, especially race... more Research on perceived discrimination has overwhelmingly focused on one form of discrimination, especially race discrimination, in isolation from other forms. The present article uses data from the Black Youth Culture Survey, a nationally representative, racially and ethnically diverse sample of 1,052 adolescents and young adults to investigate the prevalence, distribution, and mental and physical health consequences of multiple forms of perceived discrimination. The findings suggest that disadvantaged groups, especially multiply disadvantaged youth, face greater exposure to multiple forms of discrimination than their more privileged counterparts. The experience of multiple forms of discrimination is associated with worse mental and physical health above the effect of only one form and contributes to the relationship between multiple disadvantaged statuses and health. These findings suggest that past research may misspecify the discrimination-health relationship and fails to account for the disproportionate exposure to discrimination faced by multiply disadvantaged individuals.
15 views
Seen by:Education, empowerment and community based structural reinforcement: An HIV prevention response to mass incarceration and removal
Co-authored with Jeffery Draine (Temple Uniersity) and Philippe Bourgois (University of Pennsylvania)
Published in the International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, July 2011
In the context of US urban jails, incarceration is often seen as an opportune intervention point for prevention... more In the context of US urban jails, incarceration is often seen as an opportune intervention point for prevention interventions in public health. For the detained individual, it is an opportunity to reflect on individual choices and the potential for changes in one's life course. For population focused public health professionals, jail detention facilities represent a concentration of health risks, and an opportunity to have an impact on a significant portion of those at risk for HIV and other health concerns. This paper presents an innovative education and empowerment model that bridges across jail walls, beginning on the inside, and continuing on the outside of jail where individuals continue to be challenged and supported toward positive health and social choices. The intervention also seeks to foment community activism in the communities to which jail detainees return, thus aiming to have a structural impact. This paper examines both the intervention model and the challenges of examining the effectiveness claims for the intervention at multiple levels.
17 views
The Impact of Regime-Type on Health: Does Redistribution Explain Everything?
by Simon Wigley
Co-authored with Arzu Akkoyunlu
Many scholars claim that democracy improves population health. The prevailing explanation for this is that democratic... more Many scholars claim that democracy improves population health. The prevailing explanation for this is that democratic regimes distribute health-promoting resources more widely than autocratic regimes. The central contention of this article is that democracies also have a significant pro-health effect independently of public redistributive policies. After establishing the theoretical plausibility of the non-distributive effect a panel of 153 countries for the years 1972 to 2000 is used to examine the relationship between extent of democratic experience and life expectancy. We find that democratic governance continues to have a salutary effect on population health even when controls are introduced for the distribution of health-enhancing resources. Data for 50 autocratic countries for the years 1994 to 2007 is then used to examine whether that press freedom has a positive impact on life expectancy independently of government responsiveness.
The Intersectional Determinants of Systematic Global Health Inequality: The Effects of International Policy
Paper for intro Social Health class - 2011
Dirty Hands and Unclean Practices: How Medical Neglect and the Preponderance of Stress Illustrates How Medicine Harms Rather Than Helps
published in 'Journal of Black Masculinity,' 2012
As medicine emerged as a humanist and scientific
discipline positioned to cure and eradicate disease, there... more
As medicine emerged as a humanist and scientific
discipline positioned to cure and eradicate disease, there were
great hopes that it could additionally transform race relations
because of the principles of universalism—particularly the notion
of value-free clinicians with good hearts and helping hands. Yet,
American medicine, like other White controlled institutions,
maintained a deliberate path of racial marginalization and gross
inequalities mainly ensconced in racial ideology over the Black
body. Centuries-old racist practices have consequences and
repercussions for its targets. As this paper demonstrates, looking at the experiences of African Americans, the effects of living with unrelenting racism(s) has produced significant physiological damage in the form of the stress response.
15 views
Seen by:"They think we're OK and we know we're not". A qualitative study of asylum seekers' access, knowledge and views to health care in the UK
Authored by Catherine O'Donnell, Maria Higgins, Rohan Chauhan and Kenneth Mullen and published in BMC Health Services Research
BackgroundThe provision of healthcare for asylum seekers is a global issue. Providing appropriate and culturally... more BackgroundThe provision of healthcare for asylum seekers is a global issue. Providing appropriate and culturally sensitive services requires us to understand the barriers facing asylum seekers and the facilitators that help them access health care. Here, we report on two linked studies exploring these issues, along with the health care needs and beliefs of asylum seekers living in the UK.MethodsTwo qualitative methods were employed: focus groups facilitated by members of the asylum seeking community and interviews, either one-to-one or in a group, conducted through an interpreter. Analysis was facilitated using the Framework method.ResultsMost asylum seekers were registered with a GP, facilitated for some by an Asylum Support nurse. Many experienced difficulty getting timely appointments with their doctor, especially for self-limiting symptoms that they felt could become more serious, especially in children. Most were positive about the health care they received, although some commented on the lack of continuity. However, there was surprise and disappointment at the length of waiting times both for hospital appointments and when attending accident and emergency departments. Most had attended a dentist, but usually only when there was a clinical need. The provision of interpreters in primary care was generally good, although there was a tension between interpreters translating verbatim and acting as patient advocates. Access to interpreters in other settings, e.g. in-patient hospital stays, was problematic. Barriers included the cost of over-the-counter medication, e.g. children's paracetamol; knowledge of out-of-hours medical care; and access to specialists in secondary care. Most respondents came from countries with no system of primary medical care, which impacted on their expectations of the UK system.ConclusionMost asylum seekers were positive about their experiences of health care. However, we have identified issues regarding their understanding of how the UK system works, in particular the role of general practitioners and referral to hospital specialists. The provision of an Asylum Support nurse was clearly a facilitator to accessing primary medical care. Initiatives to increase their awareness and understanding of the UK system would be beneficial. Interpreting services also need to be developed, in particular their role in secondary care and the development of the role of interpreter as patient advocate.
Asylum seekers' expectations of and trust in general practice: a qualitative study
Authored by Catherine O'Donnell, Maria Higgins, Rohan Chauhan and Kenneth Mullen and published in British Journal of General Practice
Background: The UK has substantial minority populations of short-term and long-term migrants from countries with... more Background: The UK has substantial minority populations of short-term and long-term migrants from countries with various types of healthcare systems. Aim: This study explored how migrants' previous knowledge and experience of health care influences their current expectations of health care in a system relying on clinical generalists performing a gatekeeping role. Design of study: Two qualitative methods. Setting: Glasgow, UK. Method: Focus groups or semi-structured interviews were conducted with 52 asylum seekers. Analyses identified several areas where previous experience affected current expectations. An overview of health systems in each country of origin was established by combining responders' accounts with World Health Organization statistics. Results: Asylum seekers had previous experience of a diverse range of healthcare systems, most of which were characterised by a lack of GPs and direct access to hospital-based specialists. For some responders, war or internal conflict resulted in a complete breakdown of healthcare systems. Responders' accounts also highlighted the difficulties that marginalised groups had in accessing health care. Although asylum seekers were generally pleased with the care they received from the NHS, there were areas where they experienced difficulties: confidence in their GP and access to hospital-based specialists and medication. These difficulties encountered might be explained by previous experience. Conclusion: GPs and other healthcare professionals need to be aware that experience of different systems of care can have an impact on individuals' expectations in a GP-led system. If these are not acknowledged and addressed, a lack of confidence and trust in the GP may undermine the effectiveness of the clinical consultation.
Do health improvement programmes fit with MRC guidance on evaluating complex interventions?
Authored by Mhairi Mackenzie, Catherine O'Donnell, Emma Halliday, Sanjeev Sridharan, Steve Platt and published in the British Medical Journal
What is the 'problem' that outreach work seeks to address and how might it be tackled? Seeking theory in a primary health prevention programme
Mackenzie,M.; Turner,F.; Platt,S.; Reid,M.; Wang,Y.; Clark,J.; Sridharan,S.; O'Donnell,C.
BMC Health Services Research 2011; 11: 350
BACKGROUND:Preventive approaches to health are disproportionately accessed by the more affluent and recent health... more
BACKGROUND:Preventive approaches to health are disproportionately accessed by the more affluent and recent health improvement policy advocates the use of targeted preventive primary care to reduce risk factors in poorer individuals and communities. Outreach has become part of the health service response. Outreach has a long history of engaging those who do not otherwise access services. It has, however, been described as eclectic in its purpose, clientele and mode of practice; its effectiveness is unproven.Using a primary prevention programme in the UK as a case, this paper addresses two research questions: what are the perceived problems of non-engagement that outreach aims to address; and, what specific mechanisms of outreach are hypothesised to tackle these.
METHODS:Drawing on a wider programme evaluation, the study undertook qualitative interviews with strategically selected health-care professionals. The analysis was thematically guided by the concept of 'candidacy' which theorises the dynamic process through which services and individuals negotiate appropriate service use.
RESULTS:The study identified seven types of engagement 'problem' and corresponding solutions. These 'problems' lie on a continuum of complexity in terms of the challenges they present to primary care. Reasons for non-engagement are congruent with the concept of 'candidacy' but point to ways in which it can be expanded.
CONCLUSIONS:The paper draws conclusions about the role of outreach in contributing to the implementation of inequalities focused primary prevention and identifies further research needed in the theoretical development of both outreach as an approach and candidacy as a conceptual framework
Delivering a national programme of anticipatory care in primary care: a qualitative study
O'Donnell,C.A.; Mackenzie,M.; Reid,M.; Turner,F.; Clark,J.; Wang,Y.; Sridharan,S.; Platt,S.
British Journal of General Practice 2012; 62: e288-e296
Background: Primary prevention often occurs against a background of inequalities in health and health care. Addressing... more
Background: Primary prevention often occurs against a background of inequalities in health and health care. Addressing this requires practitioners and systems to acknowledge the contribution of health-related and social determinants and to deal with the lack of interconnectedness between health and social service providers. Recognising this, the Scottish Government has implemented a national programme of anticipatory care targeting individuals aged 45-64 years living in areas of socioeconomic deprivation and at high risk of cardiovascular disease. This programme is called Keep Well.
Aim: To explore the issues and tensions underpinning the implementation of a national programme of anticipatory care.
Design and setting: A qualitative study in five Wave 1 Keep Well pilot sites, located in urban areas of Scotland, and involving 79 general practices.
Method: Annual semi-structured interviews were conducted with 74 key stakeholders operating at national government level, local pilot level and within general practices, resulting in 118 interviews. Interview transcripts were analysed using the framework approach.
Results: Four underlying tensions were identified. First, those between a patient-focused general-practice approach versus a population-level health-improvement approach, linking disparate health and social services; secondly, medical approaches versus wider social approaches; thirdly, a population-wide approach versus individual targeting; and finally, reactive versus anticipatory care.
Conclusion: Implementing an anticipatory care programme to address inequalities in cardiovascular disease identified several tensions, which need to be understood and resolved in order to inform the development of such approaches in general practice and to develop systems that reduce the degree of fragmentation across health and social services
Reaching the hard-to-reach? Conceptual puzzles and challenges for policy and practice.
Mackenzie,M.; Reid,M.; Turner,F.; Wang,Y.; Clark,J.; Sridharan,S.; Platt,S.; O'Donnell,C.
Journal of Social Policy 2012 (on-line first)
Confronting HIV and Mass Imprisonment: Two Intersecting Epidemics
Co-authored with Coco Jervis
September 2008
Diversity within: Deconstructing Aboriginal community health in Wikwemikong Unceded Indian Reserve
2008
This paper analyzes the community health of the Wikwemikong Unceded Indian Reserve (WUIR), Ontario, Canada. Results... more This paper analyzes the community health of the Wikwemikong Unceded Indian Reserve (WUIR), Ontario, Canada. Results are reported from fieldwork including participant observation, key informant interviewing and self-reported data measuring health status, risk behaviour, place of residence, self-identity, and personal history extracted from 350 interviews conducted during a community-wide needs assessment. The research aimed to create a health plan for the community; however, subsequent analysis of the needs assessment results indicates that internal diversity exists in health status and needs between the seven villages that comprise WUIR. The analysis suggests variation in health status and risk-taking behaviour among community members may be related to varying colonial histories among the villages. The implications of intra-community variation in health status in First Nations are discussed in relation to influential health policy theories such as the determinants of health and health transfer policy in Canada.
HIV and Chemoprophylaxis, the importance of considering social structures alongside biomedical and behavioral intervention
Roberts, E. T., & Matthews, D. D. (In press). HIV and Chemoprophylaxis, the importance of considering social structures alongside biomedical and behavioral intervention. Social Science & Medicine. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2012.02.016
This manuscript draws connections between chemoprophylaxis and the biomedical model of disease that emphasizes... more This manuscript draws connections between chemoprophylaxis and the biomedical model of disease that emphasizes individual behavior. We argue that chemoprophylactic HIV interventions have limited utility at the population level, and that structural interventions need to be prioritized. We use the recent CAPRISA 004 and iPrEx trials to (a) critique the utility of these trials from a public health perspective by highlighting the difference between efficacy and effectiveness, (b) apply an alternative theory of health behavior as a way to reorient the field towards the discussion of the need to employ structural interventions, and (c) examine two aspects of HIV prevention efforts – funding structures and iatrogenic effects of biomedical approaches – as a means of overcoming obstacles to more widespread adoption of structural interventions.

