Freud and free-will: Fact, fantasy, and philosophy
by Simon Boag
Boag, S. (2011). Freud and free-will: Fact, fantasy, and philosophy [Review of the book Freud, the reluctant philosopher]. PsycCRITIQUES-Contemporary Psychology: APA Review of Books, 56 (6).
7 views
Seen by:Masochism and the Modern Ethical Ideal: Between Literary and Scientific Visibility
Published in the Journal of Literature and Psychology
Psicoanálisis y pedagogía. Un análisis de las Actas de la Sociedad Psicoanalítica de Viena (1906-1923)
Vallejo, M. (2008), “Psicoanálisis y pedagogía. Un análisis de las Actas de la Sociedad Psicoanalítica de Viena (1906-1923)”, Anuario de Investigaciones. Facultad de Psicología (UBA), Volumen XV, Tomo II, pp. 179-186
This work describes the presence of pedagogic problems
in the records of the debates held by the viennese
in the records of the debates held by the viennese
psychoanalysts during the first two decades of the last
century. This text begins with some considerations about
the so called reception studies and proposes an examination
of the hypothesis and sentences that Freud and
his disciples made about the children education -and
fundamentally about the sexual enlightenment- during
the wednesday meetings. Consequently, the article remarks
that those sentences were a continuation of a
concern about the relationships inside the family and the
function of other socialization institutions
Psicoanálisis y eugenesia: Apuntes para una historia olvidada. El ejemplo de Rudolf von Urbantschitsch
Vallejo, M. (2010) “Psicoanálisis y eugenesia: Apuntes para una historia olvidada. El ejemplo de Rudolf von Urbantschitsch”, Memorias del II Congreso Internacional de Investigación y Práctica Profesional en Psicología - XVII Jornadas de Investigación y Sexto Encuentro de Investigadores en Psicología del Mercosur. Facultad de Psicología, Tomo IV, pp. 403-405, ISSN 1667-6750.
The purpose of this paper is to analyze the intellectual development of a secondary participant of
the early... more
The purpose of this paper is to analyze the intellectual development of a secondary participant of
the early history of psychoanalysis: Rudolf von Urbantschitsch (1879-1964), a Viennese doctor that
in 1908 entered to the Wednesday Psychological Society, and who during his long life used usually
the freudian concepts. On several occasions this psychoanalyst accepted the use of eugenical
practices. The goal of this communication is to describe the reasoning he showed, and demonstrate
that the combination between psychoanalysis and eugenics was not an isolated fact.
35 views
Seen by:Schoenberg’s Vienna, Freud’s Vienna: Re-Examining the Connections between the Monodrama Erwartung op. 17 and the Early History of Psychoanalysis
The Musical Quarterly. 93: 1 (Spring 2010): 144-181.
Arnold Schoenberg’s 1909 monodrama Erwartung, op. 17, is commonly
characterized as a “psychoanalytic” work, for... more
Arnold Schoenberg’s 1909 monodrama Erwartung, op. 17, is commonly
characterized as a “psychoanalytic” work, for several reasons: first,
because of a putative family connection between the monodrama’s
librettist, Dr. Marie Pappenheim, and Bertha Pappenheim, better known
as “Anna O.,” the first patient to undergo “the talking cure”; second,
because of Theodor Adorno’s suggestion that Erwartung, a recondite
exercise in atonality and athematicism, may be understood as a kind of
psychoanalytic case history in its own right; and lastly, because the
monodrama is roughly contemporaneous with Schoenberg’s own writings
on the relationship between art and the unconscious, which appear to
directly reflect a Freudian milieu and a familiarity with psychoanalytic
literature and theory. The suggestion that Marie and Bertha Pappenheim
were related, and the notion that Erwartung comprises a generalized
reflection of a Freudian Zeitgeist—and/or that it has some kind of psychoanalytic
program—have become musicological truisms, though much
of the research on the subject lacks depth and the evidence is often
scant. This essay asserts that Erwartung clearly demonstrates, through
its overarching themes and textual details, an awareness of both the
history and practice of Freudian psychoanalysis. The essay offers a
summary and analysis of these themes and details and an investigation
of the monodrama’s background and context. In so doing, it seeks to
answer the questions, “How much did Schoenberg really know about
Freud?” and “How much influence did Freud and psychoanalysis have
on Schoenberg’s compositional aesthetic during his early atonal period?”
The answers lie within the text of Erwartung, with Marie Pappenheim,
and in recontextualizing “Freud’s Vienna” and the monodrama’s place
in it.
"La formation du concept de perversion au XIXe siècle en France"
This article has been published in L'information psychiatrique, vol. 88, n°1, janv. 2012, pp. 39-49
"The formation of the concept of mental perversion in the 19th century in France." In this article, we... more
"The formation of the concept of mental perversion in the 19th century in France." In this article, we assess the emergence
of the psychiatric concept of “perversion” in the 19th century. We focus on two points. First, despite its common usage,
the psychiatric concept of perversion should not be based on the theologico-moral notion of “perverse” but from a medical
notion of “perversion”, which refers to the alteration of humours and then the qualitative alterations of instincts.We analyse
how the clinical knowledge of the various qualitative deviations of instincts has developed within psychiatric knowledge.
Second, we show that, in contrast, the concept of “perversion” has offered the psychiatrists a way of getting inside the
medicolegal field and to deal with the juridico-moral concept of “perversity”, a concept that became decisive in penal
practices after 1820.We evaluate this opposition between “perversity” and “perversion” and show how the “constitutional
pervert” eventually emerged in the 1860s.
140 views
Seen by: and 1 morePhD Thesis Abstract (2006)
PhD Thesis Abstract
______
This work maps the breast(s) as an obsession in late-capitalist culture, positing... more
PhD Thesis Abstract
______
This work maps the breast(s) as an obsession in late-capitalist culture, positing this spectacular object as a pedagogical device, a topos, around which to teach a lesson. This is executed through five different approaches, combining different theoretical models.
Chapter One interrogates discourses on breastfeeding and the ideology of motherhood through an exploration of wet-nursing, Rousseau’s writings on breastfeeding, and the French Republic’s problematic appropriation of breasts as symbols of liberty.
Chapter Two locates the breast within Foucault’s history of sexuality; the emergence of a new field of knowledge, exemplified by a theoretical model which posits the breast as sexual organ par excellence, psychoanalysis. According to this model, the breast is a profound presence in infancy and its loss, necessitated by culture, is irreparable: the breast remains throughout life as that which is longed for but cannot be recuperated.
These two chapters which constitute Part I,
largely reflect male concerns with the maternal breast, but also seek to question these attempts to manage the female body, showing how breasts exceed management through discourse.
Part II, Chapter Three takes on recent concerns over breasts as visually pleasing (fun) objects in contemporary western culture, deeply implicated in the
gendered politics of the gaze, repeatedly constructed through fetishistic regimes of hetero-masculine looking which averts from a recognition of woman’s sexual
difference.
Chapter Four is a response to the breast in discourse of Part I and the visual breast in popular culture, exploring different modalities of embodiment, anatomies of breasts, through Beauvoir’s notion of gender as becoming: a process of physiological change and enculturated learning. I argue that a celebration of this anatomic pliability may involve rethinking embodied womanhood after the loss of a breast – to herald a poetic imaginary that celebrates the loss and mourning of a breast, not as castration, but as another link in the chain of becoming.
Chapter Five
encapsulates tensions within this project; seeking to integrate the idealised breasts with modern anxieties around breasted difference/breast-loss through recognition of the breast as a Kleinian container of both good and bad, bringing in the creative sphere of maternal/infantile psychic experiences around incorporation of the mother’s good milk.
Only through recognition of “the good enough mother” in all her complexities can the breast faithfully be put to use as a source for literary, theoretical and artistic productions - inscriptions in Cixousian white ink.
Thinking Where I Am (K)not: Resistance, Language and the Unconscious in Freud and Lacan
Masters Thesis, 2011
In this work I discuss the relevance of the psychoanalytic concepts of resistance and transference for an... more In this work I discuss the relevance of the psychoanalytic concepts of resistance and transference for an understanding of language from a psychoanalytic point of view, in particular how it is that human beings relate to language and whether or not we can conceive of a relation of reference between word and thing from the point of view of Jacques Lacan’s notion of the subject of the unconscious. This investigation takes us through the notion of reference and how it is possible (or not) for language to even refer to anything outside of itself from a psychoanalytic point of view. How does psychoanalysis force us to confront our prejudices about language? How might we understand the status of knowledge differently (and productively) after Lacan, taking into account the concept of the unconscious as “structured like a language”? We are concerned throughout with understanding the unconscious in material terms.
22 views
Seen by:Anti-Social Engineering the Hyper-Manipulated Self
by Brian Taylor
When one does philosophy, one dismantles strings of concepts into their respective parts to examine both the parts... more
When one does philosophy, one dismantles strings of concepts into their respective parts to examine both the parts themselves and the relationships the parts have with each other. This semantic reduction provides us the best possible opportunities for finding truth. This was exactly the type of skill Brian Taylor needed to write his new book Anti-Social Engineering the Hyper-Manipulated Self, postpaper publishing, ISBN: 978-0-557-99909-5 http://stores.lulu.com/postpaper
The book began as a series of blogged essays in a response to the “Authenticity” movement presented by the like of Eckhart Tolle, Andrew Cohen and to a lesser extent, Dr. Phil. These men, and others, were coming to conclusions on the idea of authenticity that were, among other things, subjective fallacies, rife with interpretation and possibly counterproductive. On the other side of the coin we had skeptical guru Michael Shermer or perhaps Richard Dawkins making up one half of the “four horseman of the non-apocalypse.” These men, “scientists,” were and still are guilty of the same faults as their spiritual counterparts, interpretations rather than knowledge. Brian Taylor wanted to know, “Are there any actual answers in the arena of the self and its power?” As it turns out, reality is far stranger than ever before known and we actually know so much less than we think we do, if it can be said that we know anything authentically, at all.
After four years of research into our ideas about the self through the ages, the sciences of the self and what the self is, this book comes to the conclusion that the modern self, you and I today, are not only manipulated, but that manipulation is sought out, required and pre-programmed. This is a book about how we are all being intentionally hyper-manipulated without our knowledge, by whom and to what end.
To “anti-social engineer” is to counter this phenomenon of modernity through critical consciousness, dubbed “assignee's prerogative.” This self direction is aimed toward eudaemonia, which is an Aristotelian idea roughly meaning “happiness and promotion,” and it is further suggested that virtue is found in the mean between excess and deficiency, in these concerns. This sounds rather simple in such a paragraph form, rest assured, chasing the meanings and relationships of these ideas to any philosophical depth requires a maze of rabbit holes and someone to guide you through them. Taylor is nothing if not thorough in this regard.
Entertaining, personal, conversational, exact and profound, this book has a strange undercurrent, almost a charge running through it. Most clearly defined in it's most opinionated moments, there is a subtext, not a call to arms but to a social contract. Taylor says, throughout the book, that it is specifically battling social engineering, the command, hidden or not, “think this about that.” Yet, he too wants us to think a certain way, a centrist “golden mean,” a path of no extremes. Making an argument against his ideas is difficult, regardless of the talking points he uses. (These vary from possible moral objections we may hold for prostitution or murder, to social norms such as supporting the troops or the war on terror.) In his most controversial moments, when objectivity is at its thinnest, the author's existentialism shines through and he suggests it's better to not claim to know something than to suspect something incorrectly. The exception to this rule is when the social engineering is secret, malicious, degenerative or merely in error.
There are things that we can do anti-social engineer our hyper-manipulated selves and Taylor spells these tasks out clearly. Firstly, social engineering, be it delivered by a television commercial, ideology, civility, social construct, etc. is to be expected and recognized. Then Taylor presents us his Philosophy Generator which is described as “a dismantling of paradigm” and a way to determine if any particular social engineering is more persuasive or manipulative. If we are able to first know what it is we are deciding, then do our best possible thinking on the matter, which is what working through the Generator is for, we should be able to be confident in our decision, whatever it may be. Furthermore, given the standardization of awareness, contemplation and centrist philosophy, it should be expected that the same benefit experienced by individuals would transfer to societies.
The book ends with a chapter called “God wears a yellow hat.” It is concluded with a list of 24 interesting intentions, (23 actually, one of them is missing,) this list is not meant to be a complete index of the topics discussed, but rather an indication of the book's scope. The war on terror, the war on drugs, food transportation, consumerism, capitalism, communism, false flags, dehumanization via technology, God, 2012, patriotism, culture, globalization, human rights and religion. There is an entire chapter devoted to a reasonable discussion between the two sides divided over the conspiracies associated with September 11, 2001. This book discusses conspiracy as it dismantles thought, which is a strange dichotomy. Taylor seems to want to convince us that he is a reasonable man, with a reasonable method and if such a man can find a reasonable conspiracy, we can take the suggestion from the fringe to the mainstream. He may be right. However, this is not a conspiracy book, this is a book about thinking.
One comes away from the experience of reading this book enticed to do more and this is the goal. Anti-Social Engineering the Hyper-Manipulated Self is about taking responsibility and looking ahead, prudently. It doesn't want to take anything away from you, you're entitled to have your beliefs as the author has his. We need our beliefs and we even need social engineering, these things are part of a natural, healthy species. The dangers of our beliefs are represented by the lack of awareness of them and the inability to think critically about them. Taylor argues that, if in fact we are not thinking well about the things we believe, we are not living up to the reasonable purpose we have as human beings. This appreciation of hyper-reality and our place in it defines our authenticity and is the promise expressed by the 21st Century Enlightenment.
125 views
Seen by: and 23 more“Imputaciones de colaboracionismo, moralidad política y los orígenes y difusión del lacanismo en la Argentina”.
Etnografías Contemporáneas 5 (5): 75-107. Instituto de Altos Estudios Sociales (IDAES), Universidad Nacional de General San Martín. ISSN 1666-5945.
En este trabajo me centraré en las atribuciones de complicidad con la dictadura militar, formuladas... more En este trabajo me centraré en las atribuciones de complicidad con la dictadura militar, formuladas principalmente durante las décadas de 1980 y 1990, al psicoanálisis lacaniano en la Argentina. Apelando a materiales provenientes de mi trabajo etnográfico con psicoanalistas desde 1988 hasta 1999, así como diversas fuentes escritas de índole pública (notas periodísticas y columnas de opinión en diarios y revistas de circulación masiva nacional; artículos en revistas y libros psicoanalíticos, psiquiátricos y psicológicos), pretendo mostrar cómo estos cargos de complicidad política pueden ser analizados como imputaciones de malignidad como un asunto propiamente de moralidad política. Aunque la acusación no poseía bases empíricas firmes (dedico buena parte de este artículo a mostrar que los orígenes del lacanismo no están vinculados con la última dictadura militar), sí podía resultar aceptable y coherente desde el punto de vista de una determinada interpretación de las relaciones entre el presente democrático y el pasado reciente. Como se verá en este trabajo, el lacanismo fue asociado con la última dictadura militar debido a que su genealogía no fue imaginada como una genealogía militante, o como propia de sobrevivientes o víctimas del terror, “neutralidad” y “a-politicidad” sospechosas en el nuevo contexto democrático. Finalmente, pretendo mostrar que las acusaciones de colaboracionismo, aunque en la ocasión estuvieron centradas en el lacanismo, constituyen la puesta en práctica corriente de una moralidad política que permite constituir posiciones de pureza/contaminación mediante los cuales fortalecer o debilitar legitimidades en campos sociales definidos o no como “políticos”.
Uncovering the Unconscious: Towards an Integral Psychology
unpublished.
Carl Jung, Jean Gebser, and Rudolf Steiner offer hints about an integral psychology. Carl Jung, Jean Gebser, and Rudolf Steiner offer hints about an integral psychology.
"The Medium and the Matrix: Unconscious Information and the Therapeutic Dyad, Journal of Consciousness Studies, Vol. 16, No. 9 (Sept. 2009), pp. 55-76.
Full file now available by permission of JCS
Pioneers in psychology discovered, then repudiated, the traumatic origins of dissociation. Recent scientific research... more Pioneers in psychology discovered, then repudiated, the traumatic origins of dissociation. Recent scientific research is showing how genetic predisposition plus trauma cause dissociation along with observable changes in the brain. EEG and PET scans have demonstrated that distinct neural networks lie at the base of dissociative states, with differences as striking as blindness vs. sight. Research is pointing as well to the role of the right hemisphere in developing a core sense of self through the mother-infant bond and dividing it in response to childhood trauma and later stressors. Analysts from the nineteenth through the twenty-first century have witnessed frequent paranormal claims, such as telepathy, in mediums and dissociative patients, and wondered at the knowledge they displayed. This paper reports case studies of an empathic therapeutic matrix where unconscious transfers of information occurred with surprising revelations and imaginative constructs that both healed the patient and changed the therapist’s own beliefs.
Le recours à l'expertise psychiatrique dans les juridictions ecclésiastiques (1850-1930)
Published in "Droit et Cultures", 60, 2010.2, p. 45-57.
Ecclesiastical courts, like civil courts, call on psychiatric expertise in criminal trials, especially where spouses... more Ecclesiastical courts, like civil courts, call on psychiatric expertise in criminal trials, especially where spouses are involved. Judges seek expert advice in determining whether one of the parties, presumably mentally deficient (furiosus), was competent to consent to, and take on, the obligations of marriage. We review cases in which ecclesiastical courts resorted to psychiatric and even gynecological expertise. Next, we consider both doctrine and jurisprudence concerning the question of madness and sexual psychopathology (as was deemed homosexuality) in the nullification procedure, mainly during the first half of the twentieth century.
37 views
Seen by:Review of Madness in Medieval Law and Custom, Wendy J. Turner, ed. .
by Andrea Jones
Published in Comitatus 42, 2011.
The Question of Lacanian Ontology: Badiou and Žižek as Responses to Seminar XI
Published in The International Journal of Žižek Studies, Volume 5, No. 2.
In Seminar XI, Lacan begins by saying that the seminar will be a response to the question of ontology posed at the... more In Seminar XI, Lacan begins by saying that the seminar will be a response to the question of ontology posed at the close of Seminar X. What emerges from this question is a new priority given to thinking the Real, as well as his famous myth of the lamella and his clearest writings on the death drive. This paper proposes that the metaphysical works of both Žižek and Badiou aim to answer the same question posed by Jacques-Alain Miller, “What is Lacan’s ontology?” While both are indebted to Lacan, their responses to this question of ontology show clear differences in their interpretations of the Real. The Real is perhaps one of the most difficult concepts to grasp since it is by definition that which cannot be symbolized, that which voids all symbolization thrust upon it. It will be argued that Badiou’s work clearly emphasizes the negative aspect of the Real, that which is really “nothing;” central here are Badiou’s writings on the Void and the Event, those punctuated instances where nothingness punches through Being and forces its way into the world. Žižek instead maintains that the Real shows itself both in lack (in the case of subjectivity) as well as in excess/surplus (as seen in trauma). By working through Žižek’s work on German Idealism and subjectivity, as well as Badiou’s metaphysics of mathematics and the Void, we will better understand both their respective readings of Lacan, as well as understand more clearly the import of Lacan’s work for contemporary metaphysics.

