Unofficial Call For Papers: Geography, Ethnicity, and Medicine
I couldn't fit this whole thing on my status update, so I'm posting it sneakily as a paper. See the 'abstract' for more details.
Unofficial Call For Papers: Geography, Ethnicity, and Medicine
This is a preliminary call for papers to... more
Unofficial Call For Papers: Geography, Ethnicity, and Medicine
This is a preliminary call for papers to form a panel proposal for the CAMWS 2013 meeting in Iowa City. Submission to this panel do not guarantee that the panel will be accepted to CAMWS, but those selected will be part of the proposal. We are trying to find individuals we don't already know who work in this area.
Within the emerging and dynamic field of ancient technical literature there is a wealth of information addressing the way ancients viewed the nature of race and ethnicity through emerging sciences like geography and medicine in the diverse cultures of the ancient Mediterranean. This panel seeks to provide scholars working in this area with a forum to explore the exciting possibilities of this new direction in ancient ethnicity studies as well as an opportunity to collaborate towards further work. We are especially interested in papers that show the interactions between one or more of the fields (geography, ethnicity, and medicine--think Airs, Waters, Places or Pliny the Elder type stuff, maybe), and welcome contributions from any time period, so long as the focus is on the ancient Mediterranean.
Abstracts ca. 100-200 words should be submitted to Rebecca Kennedy (kennedyr@denison.edu) and Molly Jones-Lewis (mollyayn@gmail.com) by July 6, 2013.
Tribal Identity in the Roman World: The Case of the Psylloi
Presented at CAMWS 2011 and currently under conversion to book chapter format for a larger collection of essays exploring intersections of geography, ethnicity, and medicine in antiquity.
This paper presents and examines the testimonia about the Psylloi, a North African tribe known for their... more
This paper presents and examines the testimonia about the Psylloi, a North African tribe known for their quasi-magical abilities in curing and, at times, using poison. First mentioned in Herodotus as a extinct tribe, the name emerges once more in Pliny, Plutarch, Strabo, Lucan, and Aelian connected to a contemporary group that was often employed in the Roman military specifically for their reputed ability to cure the bites of snakes and scorpions.
The paper considers the question of whether this ethnic group was consciously reviving Herodotus' lost Psylloi in an effort to further their reputation with a name familiar to Greek-speaking intellectuals. An alternate version of their story is preserved in Pliny the Elder in which they were not destroyed by a sandstorm (as Herodotus claims), but were instead driven from their lands to take up settlement elsewhere. It is likely that this alternate story was produced by the (new?) Psylloi in order to bolster their reputation among their Greek-speaking clientele.
The paper also addresses the ways in which Roman authors in particular classified them as a incompletely conquered people. For instance, Pliny the Elder (the author who provides the most information about this group) portrays them plotting to import scorpions into Italy in order to boost their poison-curing business (N. H. 11.89), holding demonstrations in which they display their ability to withstand the poisons of toads (25.123), and ritually expose their children to snake-bite in order to prove paternity (N. H. 7.14). In other authors, the Psylloi are far more helpful, though no less formidable. In Lucan's Pharsalia 9.907 they aid Cato's Romans against snakebite, and in Greek-speaking authors their powers likewise serve Roman interests (c.f. Strabo 13.1, Suetonius Aug. 17.4, and Plutarch Cato 57). I argue that the dangerous aspect of their reputation was central to the success of the Psylloi in promoting themselves (as they seem to have done); a power that is dangerous is likewise a power that is effective, and for this reason it was in this group's best interest to appear both dangerous and amenable to serving their Roman masters.
Finally, the paper will discuss the other groups who were similarly identified with poison and antidotes: the Ophiogenes and the Marsi. The Marsi in particular presented a challenge to the Psylli inasmuch as they represented an Italian alternative to these North African poison specialists, and it is possible that there was some competition between the two in self-presentation as the superior poison curers.
An examination of the Psylloi presents a strategy used by an ancient group in order to build a cohesive identity in the pluralistic environment of the late Republic and Empire. The surviving testimonia provide a tantalizing glimpse of the ways in which they built and used a one-dimensional image for gain within a system that comodified ethnic groups (i.e. Catullus' Bithyinian litter-bearers or Thracian gladiators) within its marketplace.
Recensione a: P. Li Causi,Generare in comune. Teorie e rappresentazioni dell'ibrido nel sapere zoologico dei Greci e dei Romani
Book Review published in "Technai. An international Journal for ancient Science and Technology" 1 (2010), 189-193
Recensione a: P. Li Causi,Generare in comune. Teorie e rappresentazioni dell'ibrido nel sapere zoologico dei Greci e dei Romani
Book Review published in "Technai. An international Journal for ancient Science and Technology" 1 (2010), 189-193
Un vaso celtibérico con problema
Published in Cuadernos de Arqueologia de la Universidad de Navarra 18, 2010 [ISSN 1133-1542], pp. 177-199.
This paper describes a vase found in Clunia (Hispania Citerior) about 1930, and decorated with a geometric drawing... more
This paper describes a vase found in Clunia (Hispania Citerior) about 1930, and decorated with a geometric drawing with numerical labels and a question asking to calculate the length of one side. This kind of arithmetic operations are known in papyri and ostraka from Eastern regions, but the pot seems to be one of the few instances of a calculation described in the West and the only one ever found in Spain.
El artículo describe una vasija cerámica encontrada en el alfar de los Pedregales (Clunia, Hispania Citerior) hacia 1930 y que muestra una infrecuente decoración: una figura geométrica rotulada con cifras y acompañada del enunciado de un problema. La singularidad del vaso, pues, reside en su decoración, porque cálculos similares solo se conocen en papiros y ostraka de la parte oriental del Mediterráneo; y en que hay pocos ejemplos de operaciones matemáticas en la parte occidental del Imperio y ninguna cerámica con parecido motivo en la Península Ibérica.
67 views
Seen by: and 12 moreCultural History of the Lunar and Solar Eclipse in the Early Roman Empire
Columbia University Masters Thesis (1998)
Surveys various ancient beliefs regarding eclipse phenomena (both scientific and superstitious). Surveys various ancient beliefs regarding eclipse phenomena (both scientific and superstitious).
33 views
Seen by:Christianity Was Not Responsible for Modern Science
In John Loftus, ed., The Christian Delusion: Why Faith Fails (Prometheus 2010): 396-419.
Extensive refutation of the new but popular Christian apologetic claim that Christianity not only caused the... more Extensive refutation of the new but popular Christian apologetic claim that Christianity not only caused the Scientific Revolution but was the only worldview that could have done so. Extensively surveys scholarship on ancient science demonstrating every component of this claim to be entirely false, and identifies several clear fallacies in the very structure of the claim itself.
The Deadly Styx River and the Death of Alexander
Co-authored with Antoinette Hayes, Research Toxicologist, Pfizer Pharmaceuticals
revised version, May 2011
Plutarch, Arrian, Diodorus, Justin, and other ancient historians report that rumors of poisoning arose after the death... more Plutarch, Arrian, Diodorus, Justin, and other ancient historians report that rumors of poisoning arose after the death of Alexander in Babylon in 323 BC. Alexander’s close friends suspected a legendary poison gathered from the River Styx in Arcadia, so corrosive that only the hoof of a horse could contain it. It’s impossible to know the real cause of Alexander’s death, but a recent toxicological discovery may help explain why some ancient observers believed that Alexander was murdered with Styx poison. We propose that the river harbored a killer bacterium that can occur on limestone rock deposits. This paper elaborates on our Poster presentation, Toxicological History Room, XII International Congress of Toxicology, Barcelona, 19-23 July 2010, and Society of Toxicology Annual Meeting, Washington DC, March 2011.
Rhetorical uses of mathematical harmonics in Philo and Plutarch
by David Creese
In: Aude Doody, Sabine Föllinger and Liba Taub (eds.), Structures and Strategies in Ancient Greek and Roman Technical Writing, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 43 (2012), 258-69.
The branch of harmonic science called ‘canonics’ is rarely discussed outside specialist literature in Greek antiquity.... more The branch of harmonic science called ‘canonics’ is rarely discussed outside specialist literature in Greek antiquity. Two exceptions are discussed in this paper: one reference to the science and another to its practitioners, both in non-specialist texts (Philo of Alexandria, De opificio mundi 96; Plutarch, Quaestiones convivales III.9). Because both texts contain erroneous claims given under the authority of canonics, the interpretation of these references is problematic. The two passages are discussed and compared in an attempt to account for the errors contained in them, and to expose the rhetorical aims of each author and the methods by which the technical terms and concepts of an ancient science could be made to serve very different ends in a non-scientific context.
Instruments and empiricism in Aristoxenus’ Elementa harmonica
by David Creese
In: Carl A. Huffman (ed.), Aristoxenus of Tarentum: Discussion. Rutgers Studies in the Classical Humanities, vol. 17 (New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction, 2012), 29-63.
This paper concerns the methodological implications of a passage in Aristox. El. harm. book 2, in which Aristoxenus... more This paper concerns the methodological implications of a passage in Aristox. El. harm. book 2, in which Aristoxenus sets out a procedure designed to settle a controversy over the measurement of an important musical interval (the perfect fourth) by others smaller than it. The procedure cannot be done without an instrument, but Aristoxenus does not mention this; and yet since the participation of the reader’s perception is both an explicit and essential component of the method, the omission carries serious consequences: an instrument is needed to provide evidence for perception to judge. The purpose of this paper is to address the problems caused by this omission, to suggest some possible reasons for it, and in the process to define more clearly the role of instruments as tools of persuasion in Aristoxenus’ harmonics.
Ascoltare i numeri, vedere i suoni: la funzione degli strumenti e dei diagrammi nella scienza armonica greca
by David Creese
In D. Castaldo, D. Restani and C. Tassi (eds.), Il sapere musicale e i suoi contesti da Teofrasto a Claudio Tolemeo (Ravenna: Longo, 2009), 67-83
Archimedes on the Dimensions of the Cosmos
Isis 74 (1983) 234-242
In the fourth book of "Refutation all heresies" the author (Hippolytus of Rome) reports on some astronomical... more In the fourth book of "Refutation all heresies" the author (Hippolytus of Rome) reports on some astronomical theories ascribed to Aristarchus, Apollonius, Archimedes and perhaps one other whose name is lost. The most extensive account concerns a theory of the distances of the heavenly bodies attributed to Archimedes, but the numbers are corrupt in the text so that it is hard to reconstruct how the theory worked. In this paper I offer a reconstructionof the data, followed by an exploration of the underlying rationale for the theory, which turns out to be based on a harmonic scale. I also consider the likelihood of the claim that the theory belonged to Archimedes.
Babylonian land survey in socio-political context
in G. Selz & K. Wagensonner (eds) 2011. The Empirical Dimension of Ancient Near Eastern Studies. Wiener Offene Orientalistik 6. Vienna/Berlin: LIT Verlag: 293-323.
199 views
Seen by: and 21 more
